Photo credit: Emmanuel Black | Unsplash
Tonight is the night I lose her. Her eyes are sunken, the previous night left splotches of its sky beneath them, heavy and sagging. Head cast down, half of her face is hidden. She tries to clip herself to the buzzed conversation bouncing between all of us. Inserting a halfhearted laugh here and there. Saying, “Yeah, right.” Tobacco leaves packed with weed pass from hand to hand, in a circle around the kitchen table. Chicken thighs are steadily sizzling on the stove, a pot of yellow rice boiling, French style green beans, biscuits waiting to be buttered in the oven. And the reflection of the scene in Camry’s eyes looks like a silent picture film.
Camry is not herself tonight. She’s present in the room with us, but her mind is following a trail miles and miles away. Brittany and Nina chatter above the rocky tension, maneuvering between the open space containing both Nina’s front room and kitchen area. Midday slumps after classes always find us like this: getting high out of our minds, letting our appetites have their reign when we finish. Brittany is the culinary artist, plating whatever springs to our minds. We go for a homestyle, elbows-deep-in-flour kind of meal tonight, like each of our grandmamas would cook back home. Week by week, we take turns buying the pungent weed sacks, we rotate pitching dinner ideas, the four of us fading in, then out, of oblivion. They are Camry’s friends, friends who include me like I am one of the purse charms on her Coach bag. They do not know her like I do.
Like every moment since I met Camry last fall, I have a deep need for us to be alone.
Brittany pulls out the biscuits, the last thing to be set on our plates, drizzled with honey. Nina lights an incense, the smoking session concluded. They both string a long running joke between them and try to rope Camry in, but she fails to catch the bait. She can’t take a first bite or pop open a soda without raising her phone again, sending huge blocks of text by the minute. You have to know Camry to know this slouched over, misshaped lump sitting across from me is not her.
Unable to continue participating in the latest gossip—so and so is fucking so and so now, did you see her Instagram story—I say, “Ain’t we having an exam on Friday, Cam?”
Her pale eyelids finally lift, she stares at me blankly. We all simultaneously take our last bites.
“Yea, it sure is. We’re outta Celsius at home. Let’s go see if we can die by chugging them first or by going over sonnets for the hundredth time,” Camry says, the corners of her mouth immobile.
I let out a measly “ha,” attempting to digest the questions creeping up my throat along with the fried chicken.
We make our way into the adjoining living room area. Brittany and Nina are oblivious; they clear the table, move onto clinking wine glasses next, giggling. I keep my focus on making sure neither Camry nor I are leaving anything behind to avoid unleashing a massive eye roll. Can Camry see it now? These girls are friends fit for a good time and a good time only. They do not hold the capacity, the bandwidth, to understand her in her entirety. They laugh like hyenas, they shrink at the first friction of reality. Before we leave to go home, I wrestle with the idea of holding Camry’s eyes open, stretching them, so she can see where I differ.
“Oh hell, here comes Paige blowing everybody’s high,” Brittany playfully groans. My smile in response is tight, concealing fangs starved for blood. I could rip her apart–Nina too–for being so oblivious.
Camry falls into my sluggish steps beside me on the cobblestone pathway leading back to Wingate University. White oak trees stretch above us, their branch arms tangling in an eternal embrace. Marigold and rose and peony flower beds leave their scents on the breeze floating between us the closer we get to the dorm hall. Camry’s phone screen fills her face with a harsh light, angry words in all caps in the message she just received.
I reach out and gently place my palm on top of her phone. “Why you keep carrying on with this dude? Block him. He’s funding your tuition and all, I get that, Cam, I really do. But, fuck him. Look how he got you out here lookin’,” I say.
She looks down at the sweatpants she’s worn for the fourth time this week, runs a hand through her dry and brittle hair.
“No, I’m talking about how you look right here.” Gently jerking her chin, I let her watch me search around her face.
“You trippin’, Paige. You just said it yourself, I only put up with him so I can be standing here right now. I’m not invested in this shit. This is all a game to me. It’s a part of the act.” And she turns her phone around to show me the erratic messages demanding to know where she is, then bathing suit pictures, asking her size, dinner reservations among several deposits.
My skin prickles, tightens around every muscle. Camry met him two months ago, shuffling him through our common room, like every other boy drunk off of her charm.
Except, in our still girlish eyes, swimming in academia, still fumbling with our priorities—Josh is a full grown man compared to Wingate boys, or the local boys who fall for Camry’s slick thighs shining under street lights. They all know about Camry’s line of work; there are no pretenses. By the time they swagger out of our place, Camry’s knock off YSL wallet is an inch thicker. Josh is different. The money he gives Camry is enough to cover her tuition for this semester and the next. It’s enough to abandon the work of itching in sheer dresses and waiting for what may not come outside of hotel bars and clubs, so Camry says.
Black adorned her the first time we met during freshman year. She walked into the introductory writing course smelling like an entire rose bouquet, the perfume juxtaposing with her black combat boots, a black turtleneck tucked into a black miniskirt. Her eyeliner was sharp and pointed, making her gaze the same as a bored cat’s.
“I didn’t think there’d be too many of us in here, and what do you know? I was right!” Camry had said that day in class, tapping the back of her hand and falling into a laughing fit right beside me.
I laughed with her, the ghost of relief making itself human again since I arrived at Wingate. I ran my tongue across my teeth, checking for any lipstick stains, then smiled back at her. Out of the corner of my eye, I kept checking to see if Camry was engaged, if she stopped to jot anything down. Whenever I caught her attention, we held back laughs together that neither of us knew were waiting to burst.
Lately, like tonight, Camry gives me an offhand grin, the night lights of the building betraying the lack of color in her face. We retreat to our own sides, whereas any other time we would debrief about the smallest details of dinner together: the blunts Nina rolls are too little, was she trying to skimp out on sharing, and wasn’t Brittany a little too tipsy? Tonight, Camry has no words for me, not the slightest look over her shoulder to mutter good night.
The starry hours continue rolling on with Camry sitting at the top of my mind. My T.V remains blank. I don’t bother to scroll on my phone, either. With my back against the corner wall, ankles crossed, I stare at the pile of assignments on my desk taunting me. A volume containing the completed works of Shakespeare remains unopened, its archaic language banning me from understanding. I still remember my dread growing and Camry’s excitement about the course; she knew which professor’s class to take already, and leafed through the syllabus like it was the book of Psalms once we got it. Before she met Josh, she would be the one to give me a rundown of the assigned play while we stopped to get coffee, cold foam sitting on her top lip, her quoting Hamlet.
One night, after too many cups of wine fueled me, I had the nerve to ask Camry fluffy questions with sharp edges. What was her mom like and what did she think about Camry’s work, and what does that work do to the body, could Camry still feel?
This was a year ago when we first signed up to be roommates for our sophomore year, when the place only had the provided furniture. Camry had flicked her glossy eyes towards me, her cat eyeliner dragging me deeper into her pupils. She moved from the armchair to join me lying on blankets in front of the window. Hooking onto me, her arm in the crook of mine, her hips touching mine, she whispered the details of “a chapter she closed” before our college years started.
“I tell everybody I run into up here that I’m from Atlanta,” Camry began. “Makes me sound cooler, I think. I’m really from the city’s outskirts, Macon, Georgia. My mama never took us to Atlanta. We ain’t never go nowhere, school then back home to act out fairytales on our old rickety porch. My youngest brother was always the dragon, my oldest was a knight, and I was the princess, muddying my mama’s church slips and stuffing them in the hamper before she got home. Some of the best days, I’m tellin’ you. My mama wouldn’t come home for days, sometimes weeks at a time. I could be a stupid princess, a snotty queen, whatever I wanted when she wasn’t around.”
I tried to smooth away the goosebumps rising on her arm.
She poured herself another glass of Moscato and said, “My titties got bigger than the other girls’ back then. My first period came and went without my mama showing me how to get the blood stains outta my panties. That’s the end of it, Paige. Stories don’t really have endings, do they? They just keep on rollin’, with or without you. I guess I started giving my body away because that’s all I had to offer. I’d say it’s gotten me a few places, for damn sure off that old porch. I can’t feel a thing. And I don’t want to.”
Then, Camry lifted a finger, saying, “There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so.”
I untangled my body from hers, sitting straight up. “Huh?”
“It’s from Hamlet,” and she giggled, the two tragedies of the prince and herself colliding with amusement.
Past moments with Camry always roll around in my head, but tonight, I am careful of injecting too many assumptions on her actions. I can’t help but wonder if Brittany or Nina really know her, if Camry has traded stories with them too. Or, if she’s ever read one of her poems to them, the narrative ones, the ones that stretch across the page, the enjambments taking your hand to lead you on a journey. The first time I heard her in our workshop class I memorized the lines so I could rightfully claim to be a day one fan at her future book signing. Once, I let my fingertips ashen from dragging them along the massive dragon head on one side of her sketchpad with a long tail on the other; it accompanied a poem about black women’s anger. That’s how our duo looks–Camry, the poet, me, the novelist. In the future, our dedication pages could spell out each other’s name in stringy cursive.
It is three a.m. when I pull the covers over my head. The front door opens, then softly clicks shut. I didn’t know that would be the sound of our relationship ending.
The police officer scans Camry’s room with me, but he does not see what I see. To him, it is a young woman’s chaotic nest, filled with irreplaceable junk: strewn about outfits missing their mates, Frank Ocean album cover posters, amethyst crystals as bookends. Photo booth shots of us sit on her dresser, wedged behind a candle that smells like Christmas time. We were at Wingate’s annual fall festival in the pictures, one with model smiles, one silly, one laughing, the last taken with provided props. Camry and I had chosen the orange and sparkly pumpkin cutouts, two grinning jack-o-lanterns.
“No evidence of foul play that I can see,” Officer Dowell mutters.
Camry’s bed is unmade, her copy of the Shakespeare book open on one side, dog-eared.
I reply in some form or fashion, but my own words cannot reach my ears.
“Do you see any of her personal belongings she would keep near her? A bag? Phone? Wallet?” The officer asks, a pen hovering above a blank notepad in his hand. When I confirm that I don’t see anything unusual, the notepad is shut, pen back in its place in his shirt pocket.
“Might sound crazy, but people go off on their own all the time, Miss Irving,” he says while turning to face me, his hands now holding onto his belt loops. “Sometimes they’re dealing with things and need space.”
“Well, this dude Camry’s been seeing…he should be looked into. His name is Josh,” I blurt out, scrambling for any evidence that might make him stay.
“Last name?”
My body starts to sway. I wrap my arms around my shoulders to steady myself. I can’t tell him Josh is like the wind preceding a storm, destructive and unseen. What I remember of him is a clean haircut, him showing up in three-piece suits while Camry and I idled in sweatpants. I remember Camry commenting on him asking her to exclusively eat salads for a week or to meet him downtown at Ramaro’s and to wear heels and to not embarrass him this time.
Officer Dowell is turning to go. “Look, come on down to the station to file an official report. My advice though, kid, is to give her some time.”
I was told to wait when I got to the station, scuffing Officer Dowell’s heels with how fast I arrived. The day is darkening again, the sun slowly sliding down on my hopes. I give a sketch artist as many details about Josh as I can. I pore over my written statement about Camry, but I cannot fit all of her glory onto the page. There is no space to tell about all the warmth below Camry’s icy exterior, how–when you really got down to knowing her–there’s ocean waves of dappling sunlight right beneath her black lip liner.
The local news station does not plaster Camry’s smile for the world to take in, to look out for. They do not have a segment for missing persons that night or the next, or on the night after that. No reporters from the local paper come knocking on the door. With thousands of likes and shares on my Facebook post, complete with Camry’s smile in various lights, it is all in vain. She does not creep down the hall, slipping past our RA’s room. I wait for her to show up, hand cupped over her mouth, sealing away a conspiracy, laughing.
Late into the fall semester, on one of the lazy weekends leading up to final exams, I see Brittany and Nina in the dining hall. The months behind us have not bruised them; their faces remain Vaseline shiny, surrounded by girls whose names I can never seem to remember. When Camry first went missing, they came over and we watched five episodes of Girlfriends in silence, their presence enough of a condolence. They carry on. I get up to throw away the slimy pizza, deciding to spend my break in between classes in the library.
Leaves that were once amber lie brown and crippled, slicked down by the rainy mist onto the pavement. I head for the lower floor and into a back corner, the drop of my bookbag echoing between the bookshelves. People’s attention runs over me, accidentally looking to my right out of habit of always seeing me in tow with Camry. I am a nepo baby cut too soon from nourishment—a shadowed version of Camry without her coattails to hide under. Classmates who would have spoken to both of us before do not look in my direction.
I first heard Wingate’s library, formally known as Johnston Library, being referred to as a club from Camry. We were both sprawled across the twin sized mattress, two annotated copies of Beowulf and our laptops between us. Camry was nursing a second Celsius when she said, “Girl, you over there noddin’! We ain’t gon’ get nowhere like this, let’s go to the club.”
Snatched from the beginnings of a dream, I snapped my laptop shut. “Camry, what are you talking about? It’s a Wednesday night,” I said, annoyed. We were still freshmen then, wet behind our ears. Reckless as any other freed and young girl for the first time in our lives, some caution was still alive for me.
She closed her laptop too, sweeping up the rest of our study materials. “Hush it up, we going to Club Johnston.”
“Johnston? The fucking library?”
Camry gave me a sly smile and slipped her hand into mine, pulling me in response to my protests. When the library’s sliding doors opened, a gush of autumn wind led us in. The predominately white university we were accustomed to vanished into memory. A smile bubbled on my face to find what seemed like the campus’s entire black population on the first floor. Tools for studying were props–books standing open, pens poised in hands–because everyone was either relaxing in the plush chairs or the couches or mingling from group to group, talking rapidly. The conversations swirled, mixed, jumbled then untangled themselves. Mini chip bags and M&M wrappers from the vending machine lay crumpled across the tables. In the private, single study rooms, the doors were wide open, two to three people hanging out of them. To anyone on the hunt for some warmth that night, it was all in that room.
It is December now, and the first semester of junior year will be over in a few more days. I open a blank document on my laptop; I stare at the blinking cursor stuck between life and death, blinking endlessly. There is no more time for Camry’s name to reappear on the Dean’s List. I think about how our mothers, each of them back home, cities and cities away from each other, sent their only daughters off into the world almost three years ago now. My mama keeps sending care packages like I am away at war, and in a way, I am. Camry’s mom was never mentioned in present terms, only as a dot in Camry’s recollection. I want to reach out to her, ask her if she has been able to feel her soul break, the way they say a parent’s soul breaks when they know their child has passed away.
I find myself scrolling to Camry’s pictures on my phone. This memory and that one. All of them are only mine now.
If I could, I would tell Camry’s mom I felt the part of myself that was enamored with her daughter break the night I heard Camry leave.
Editor’s Note
Literary mystery is a hard genre to classify. One sign I look for is a character-driven story that still has a clear, mysterious plot. In “Call Her By Name” Lyric Knuckles lets Paige and Camry drive the story. Certainly, there is a mystery unfolding (which I won’t spoil), but mostly we are learning about these two women. About their past, their present, their relationship with each other, and about why they’ve become who they are.
Knuckles uses juxtaposition to interrogate binaries: a sex worker quoting Shakespeare, a library serving as a night club, two people with very different pasts forming a tight bond over a shared present. This nuance gives the characters more depth and furthers the mystery of Camry’s life and disappearance.
Josh Boldt, Editor
Story Track
Consider Nina’s Simone’s “I Wish I Knew How It Would Feel to Be Free” from the perspective of Camry in Lyric Knuckles’ “Call Her By Name.” Simone sings of a longing for liberation, which I believe is also Camry’s motive in the story; however, Camry’s pursuit of freedom has led her into a different kind of captivity. She wishes she could “break all the chains holding” her, but her past might be too hard to overcome.
Paige, too, embodies the song in lyrics like “I wish I could say all the things that I should say / Say 'em loud, say 'em clear.” She longs to help her friend find the freedom she seeks, but ultimately, it seems, her wish will go ungranted.
This song feels like the perfect way to end the season. Listen and be well. Consider this your Season Two benediction.
Josh Boldt, Editor